| YEAR | CHAMPION | COACH | SECOND | THIRD | Host Site |
| 2000 | Fremont | Kathy Greene | Model | Indiana | Washington, D.C. |
| 2001 | Model | Roberta Gage | Riverside | Fremont | Washington, D.C. |
| 2002 | Indiana | Dawn Crock | Fremont | Riverside | Fremont, CA |
| 2003 | Indiana | Cathy Dubios | Riverside | Maryland | Indianapolis, IN |
| 2004 | Maryland | Cheri Winnings | American | Model | Frederick, MD |
| 2006 | Maryland | D. Kubey & J. Randall | Fremont | Model | Riverside, CA |
| 2007 | Riverside | Stacey Hausman | Maryland | Model | Washington, D.C. |
| 2008 | Model | Vicki Bond | Riverside | Maryland | Faribault, MN |
| 2009 | Riverside | Stacey Hausman | Maryland | Indiana | Frederick, MD |
| 2010 | Indiana | Jennifer Alka | Model | Riverside | Fremont, CA |
| 2011 | Model | Emilia Nowalski | Indiana | Maryland | Austin, TX |
| 2012 | Indiana | Jennifer Alka | Model | Texas | Indianapolis, IN |
| 2013 | Riverside | Stacey Hausman | None | None | Riverside, CA |
| 2014 | Indiana | Jennifer Alka | Texas | Riverside | Indianapolis, IN |
| 2015 | Indiana | Jennifer Alka | Model | Fremont | Fremont, CA |
| 2016 | Model | Celine Daze | Indiana | Fremont | Frederick, MD |
| 2017 | Model | Celine Daze | Fremont | Indiana | Austin, TX |
| 2018 | Model | Celine Daze | Maryland | Indiana | Washington, D.C. |
| 2019 | Model | Celine Daze | Indiana | Texas | Riverside, CA |
| 2020 | Model | Celine Daze | Maryland | Texas | Indianapolis, IN |
| 2021 | No tournament due to COVID-19 pandemic | ||||
| 2022 | No tournament due to COVID-19 pandemic | ||||
| 2023 | Model | Celine Daze | Fremont | Indiana | Fremont, CA |
| 2024 | Model | Celine Daze | Fremont | Texas | Frederick, MD |
| 2025 | Model | Celine Daze | Texas | Indiana | Austin, TX |
| 2026 | St. Augustine, FL | ||||